Blog

Profit up front: when charging first pays off for your business

Costco makes most of its profit from a fee paid before the first purchase. How to tell if a subscription, club or prepaid bundle fits your business.

November 19, 2026 · Agência Primeira Página

Profit up front: when charging first pays off for your business

In his weekly letter of November 16, 2026, Brazilian entrepreneur Rony Meisler, founder of the clothing brand Reserva, gave a name to a strategy he says works for almost every business: “profit up front”. The idea is to lock in your margin at the start of the sale, in a single charge, and then deliver value to spare. His example is Costco, the American chain that charges an annual fee before the customer grabs the first cart. We checked the numbers in the company’s annual report, and they are even stronger than the letter says. Below: what the strategy is, why it works and, above all, how to tell whether it fits your business, which is the part the letter does not answer.

What “profit up front” means

Meisler’s reasoning starts from something everyone has done: the free soda refill at a fast-food chain. The customer fills the cup three times and leaves feeling clever. But a fountain soda costs the restaurant cents, and the profit on that cup was already in the price of the combo before the first refill.

The strategy has two parts:

  • Charge in one place, and early. The money that secures the margin comes in at the start: the annual fee, the monthly plan, the combo, the bundle.
  • Give away what costs you little and is worth a lot to the customer. The refill, the free sample, free delivery, store credit.

The mistake he points out is the opposite, and it is common in small businesses: charging little at the door to close the sale, then trying to win the margin back in the details, with delivery fees, add-ons and fine print. The customer feels exploited, even when they end up paying less.

Costco’s numbers, checked in the annual report

The letter quotes figures from the previous fiscal year. The annual report Costco filed with the SEC, the US securities regulator, for the year ended August 30, 2026, shows an even stronger picture:

  • Membership fees: US$ 5.9 billion for the year, up 11% from US$ 5.3 billion the year before.
  • Net income: US$ 9.2 billion, up 14%.
  • Paid members: 84.1 million, compared with 81 million a year earlier.
  • Renewal rate: 92.3% in the United States and Canada and 89.8% worldwide.
  • Price: the basic US membership costs US$ 65, the amount in place since the increase of September 1, 2024.

Put side by side, membership fees amount to about 64% of the year’s net income. That is why Costco can sell on thin margins: a large part of what is left at the end of the year was secured before any purchase. And the renewal rate shows the other side: people who paid in advance come back.

One detail the report itself explains: part of the growth in fees came from the 2024 increase. In other words, Costco raised the price of entry and nearly nine in ten members renewed anyway. That is the toughest test that customers think the trade is a good one.

The Brazilian version: the case Meisler tells

In the letter, Meisler describes something he tried at Reserva, which he calls a scar: a subscription program in which the customer paid R$ 30 a month and got the same R$ 30 back as store credit, plus free shipping, discounts on purchases and exclusive experiences. It is his account, with no published results, but the logic he describes is profit up front:

  1. The money comes in on day one. Retail rarely goes under for lack of profit; it goes under for lack of cash to pay the month’s bills.
  2. The credit costs less than it is worth. The R$ 30 in credit does not cost the brand R$ 30; it costs the production cost of the clothes the customer takes home with it.
  3. The customer who already paid comes back. They have credit to use, and when they return to the store, they usually buy something else.

When charging up front works: four questions

The letter says the strategy works for almost every business. In practice, it depends on four conditions. If your business answers “yes” to all four, it is worth testing. If it answers “no” to two or more, it is probably not the way.

  1. Do customers come back with predictable frequency? Bread, coffee, dog grooming, haircuts, classes, car washes, pet food, cleaning supplies. Charging up front turns a frequency that already exists into guaranteed revenue. If a customer buys once in a lifetime, there is nothing to bring forward.
  2. Is there something that costs you little and is worth a lot to them? Priority booking, coffee with the bread, free local delivery, the product of the day set aside, a treatment on the tenth grooming. If everything you can offer is expensive, the perk eats the margin that charging up front secured.
  3. Can your margin carry the perk? Calculate the real cost of what you give, not the list price. That gap is what makes Reserva’s credit worth more to the customer than it costs the brand.
  4. Can you deliver every month, without fail? A subscription has deadlines. If the bakery runs out of the subscriber’s bread at 7 a.m., or the pet shop has no slot for a grooming already paid for, prepayment turns into complaints.

When it does not work

  • Rare or one-off purchases. Dental implants, weddings, renovations. In these cases, what you charge up front is a deposit, which protects your schedule but does not create recurrence.
  • Customers without a routine. Tourists, occasional buyers, people passing through. The airport gift shop does not sell subscriptions.
  • Margins already cut to the bone. If the product sold with no perk at all already earns little, there is no room for the gift.
  • Perks that invite abuse. “Unlimited” without rules is an invitation to the customer who uses ten times more than average. Set the usage limit from day one: per day, per week or per month.

Do the math before launching

A simple example, with hypothetical numbers, to show the reasoning. A bakery wants to create a club: the customer pays R$ 90 a month and takes six bread rolls a day, Monday to Saturday, plus one coffee a week.

  • Cost of the bread: if each roll costs R$ 0.35 to make, 6 rolls a day over 26 days come to about R$ 55 a month.
  • Cost of the coffee: four coffees a month at R$ 1.20 each, about R$ 5.
  • Total cost of the perk: about R$ 60 if the customer uses everything. Guaranteed margin: R$ 30 per subscriber, received on the first day of the month.
  • What the spreadsheet misses, but counts: the subscriber comes into the bakery every day. On some of those days they also buy milk, butter or cake. That is where the model really pays off.

The numbers change for every business. What does not change is the order: first define where your margin is, then decide what to give away. Doing it the other way round, promising the perk and only then finding out what it costs, is the fastest way to create a club that loses money.

Formats that work for small businesses

  • Subscription with credit: the Reserva model. The customer pays a fixed amount and gets the same amount back as credit, plus a perk. Works for stores with frequent purchases.
  • Club with a fixed perk: the bakery model. A defined monthly package. Works for daily or weekly consumption.
  • Prepaid bundle: ten groomings, ten classes, ten washes, paid at once with a discount. The easiest format to start with, because it does not require monthly billing.
  • Annual membership: the Costco model. The customer pays for access to member prices or conditions. It requires volume and a price difference customers can feel.
  • Booking deposit: for businesses with appointments, such as clinics, salons and restaurants. It is not recurrence, but it protects cash flow from no-shows.

How to bill every month in Brazil

Recurring billing became simpler for small businesses in Brazil on June 16, 2025, when the Central Bank launched Pix Automático. The customer authorizes once, in their banking app, and the following payments happen on their own on the agreed date. Under the Central Bank’s rules:

  • Payment is free for the payer.
  • In the authorization, the customer sets a maximum amount per charge.
  • The customer can cancel the authorization at any time, in their own banking app.
  • The business must contract the service with its bank or payment institution, which sets the terms for receiving payments.

The alternatives still apply: recurring credit card billing, which customers know better, and bank slips, which take more work. In other countries, the equivalent is recurring card billing or direct debit through a payment platform. For those just starting, a prepaid bundle paid in full is the cheapest test: no new system, and you quickly find out whether customers accept paying first.

The precautions that prevent headaches

  • Easy cancellation. Consumer protection rules require that customers be able to cancel without red tape. Hiding cancellation may hold a customer for one more month, but it earns public complaints and loses the trust the model depends on.
  • Rules in writing from the start. Whether credit expires, whether the perk accumulates, whether the bundle has an expiry date, whether the price can be adjusted. Customers accept clear rules; what they do not accept is surprises.
  • Tax and accounting. Receiving payment in advance for a service delivered later can change how revenue is recorded. Talk to your accountant before launching.
  • Start small. Test with the customers who already come back all the time. They are proof that the frequency exists, and their feedback shows what to adjust before opening it to everyone.

Where the website comes in

A club or subscription needs a place to exist: a page that explains what the customer gets, how much it costs and how to cancel, with a button to subscribe and recurring billing connected to it. It also helps to have an area where subscribers see the credit they have, what they have used and when the next charge is. That is what separates a subscription the customer understands from one they forget they signed up for.

At our agency, we do this in two ways. In website creation, we build the club page and connect it to a ready-made billing platform. When the model needs its own rules, such as accumulated credit, tiered perks or usage control, we build it through custom software development. To think through the model before the tool, see also you don’t innovate by changing the product, but by changing how your business makes money and where the new business model comes from.

Sources

  • Rony Meisler, weekly letter “Isso é sobre você”, November 16, 2026, with the concept of profit up front and the account of Reserva’s subscription program.
  • Costco Wholesale Corporation, annual report (Form 10-K) for the fiscal year ended August 30, 2026, filed with the SEC: membership fees, net income, paid members, renewal rate and the September 2024 fee increase.
  • Central Bank of Brazil, Pix Automático guide and rules (Resolution BCB No. 360/2023 and amendments), in operation since June 16, 2025.

Frequently asked questions

What is profit up front?

It is the strategy of securing your margin at the start of the sale, in a single charge such as an annual fee, a monthly plan or a prepaid bundle, and then delivering perks that cost the business little and are worth a lot to the customer. The name was coined by Brazilian entrepreneur Rony Meisler, founder of Reserva.

How much does Costco earn from membership fees?

In the fiscal year ended August 2026, Costco received US$ 5.9 billion in membership fees, against net income of US$ 9.2 billion, according to the annual report filed with the SEC. It had 84.1 million paid members, with a renewal rate of 92.3% in the United States and Canada.

Does a subscription work for any business?

No. It works when customers come back with predictable frequency, when there is a perk that costs the business little and is worth a lot to the customer, when the margin can carry that perk and when the business can deliver every month without fail. Rare purchases, customers without a routine and thin margins are signs it does not fit.

What is the easiest way to start charging up front?

A prepaid bundle, such as ten groomings, ten classes or ten washes paid at once with a discount. It requires no monthly billing and no new system, and it quickly shows whether customers accept paying first.

How do you bill a subscription every month in Brazil?

Pix Automático, launched by the Central Bank of Brazil on June 16, 2025, lets the customer authorize once and pay automatically on the following dates, free for the payer, with a maximum amount they set and cancellation at any time. Recurring credit card billing and bank slips remain alternatives.

Can the customer cancel the subscription whenever they want?

Cancellation needs to be simple. With Pix Automático, the customer cancels the authorization in their banking app at any time. Contract rules, such as credit expiry and price adjustments, should be written down from the start to avoid complaints.